10" Polk momo vs Alpine Type R

[damick]

Looking at these two subs, and am having trouble deciding between them. Can anyone provide any details/pros/cons that will help me decide?

Car: 2007 Honda Civic w/navigation (keeping factory HU) 160w

Adding:
6.5 Alpine Type R components
6.5 Alpine Type R coaxs
Alpine F250 amp (4 ch)
Alpine M650 amp (mono)

enclosure to be used: Q-logic sealed box

Thanks!!!

[Toxis]

As of 2 years ago so who knows how much has changed since but Alpine's worked better in prefab boxes.

[Sherardp]

go for the Xtype, they will beat your back out.

[MacLeod]

Both are excellent.

The Alpine is geared more toward sheer output.

The Polk is more for SQ.