I said in the other thread, I was really pleased with the movie overall. The action sequence straight out of the gates set the tone for the whole movie. Definitely going to be a great home theater demo! :D Loved it when Anakin killed Dooku!
There were certainly somethings I didn't care for as well. i guess the one that stands out the most was when Anakin saved Darth Sidious. Sidious' face was completely cheesy. I liked how Anakin attacked Windu, leading to Windu's death. Then Anakin said, "What have I done!?" and all of a sudden he's on his knees swearing allegiance to Sidious. I would have liked an exchange between the two justifying the change to the Dark Side. Sidious could have said, "What have you done? You've taken the first step towards a greater power....a power that will help you protect the ones you love and end this bloody war. I can help you complete your transformation." Then it's cool, he's justified in the switch...go kill some younglings lol.
The other part that was kinda dumb was Padme's death. That's fine, she needed to die, but more or less dying of a broken heart is stupid. She should have just been on the brink of death after the force choke and they keep her alive long enough to save the twins. None of that, "There's nothing wrong with her, but we're losing her" crap.
That's just two gripes about the movie, but like I said 95% of it was fantastic.