XRt12 Reference Tuner

by Karl, February 14, 2005

Strengths:

The XRT is almost all you could expect from a tuner - bass power and mid-range detail and a well-developed soundstage.

Weaknesses:

It would be great if it had AM/FM. That there is no "memory" button on the remote is disappointing.

Review:

I'm sorry but I don't get the reviews from Paul and Cliff. Are they reviewing the XRT12 or Satellite Radio? Satellite Radio is not Polk's fault. XM and Sirius are never going to sound as good as a CD or even a strong FM signal on good gear. The satellite signal is compressed, like MP3. If amazing sonic performance is what you're expecting from XM then don't subscribe. XM is about the programming - period. It's about hearing music you forgot about and discovering music you were never aware of. It's like having 200 independent FM stations back when local DJs used to hand pick music and know something about it. In the days before the commercial takover and the endless repetition of sameness. XM is about sitting in the driveway until the set finishes. As for Polk's XRT12. It's the best I've heard at delivering the XM signal. It takes a signal that is mildly annoying when coming from my SkyFi and makes it more than acceptable. The XRT12 makes XM radio a respectable listening alternative for a good home hi-fi system. As soon as I opened the box, I could tell by the weight that I had a serious piece of audio gear. When I turned it on, I knew I had a keeper. The XRT delivers the imaging, the bass and detail that suprised me after listening to the SkyFi for so long! The SkyFi is back in the car where it will forever stay.

by John Scott, August 31, 2006

Strengths:

Quality reciever, output flexability, video out for on screen menu

Weaknesses:

Can only produce sound as good as XM makes it.

Review:

After having XM in my semi truck for a couple of years. I knew I had to have XM at home too. But I tried my Delphi unit at home with a home cradle. It did`nt sound that great. So, being a big fan of Polk speakers. I decided to try the XRt12. The tuner is great! I cannot say that for XM. I wish that some of the channels were not so compressed. I would be happy with less channels and less compression. After all, is it not great sound that XM was trying to sell XM on in the first place! Yes, a few stations such as the clasical music are much less compressed. But what about some of the top listened to channels? Anyway, back to the tuner review. I am able to use the optical output to get the best possible sound. Boy, it sure does make XM sound its best! They offer a couple of channels in HD now, and even though the Polk does not have the surround sound capability. It does extremely well at the stereo level.

by cliff, February 12, 2005

Strengths:

convience love the remote good programs but lacking maybe a good easy listening channel.

Weaknesses:

sound quality.sounds like i am listening to an am radio in stereo. it has to improve soon to be compete, does the other sat radio have same sound quality???

Review:

I was kinda disappointed with the sound quality! I guess i was looking for fm quality or better, very convient to use, but i must admit that the overall sound quality is poor at best, i am using a cj tube amp and martin logan cls with 2 18"subs x over is a mark levinson lnc 2...i will keep my xrt12 but will use my marantz 10b for serious lisening thanks cliff

by Paul, February 13, 2005

Strengths:

it works

Weaknesses:

too many for two

Review:

This thing is OK not better than music via satelitte or cable. Also has only 1 new age channel and scads of of other stuff. you would think with greater than 100 channels you could have at least two new age stations at >200$ not a steal

by Jeffrey Gould, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

It looks great, sounds great

Weaknesses:

hard to read the display from 6 feet away (couch)

Review:

I'm very happy with the purchase of the Polk XM tuner. It fits in with my other components and I'm very satisfied with the sound quality and button controls. I highly recommend it.

by wes felt, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality and the ability to display channel info on my tv

Weaknesses:

None so far

Review:

I have owned the Polk XM reference tuner for about a month. XM never sounded better. The sound quality is unsurpassed. I like the fact that it displays channel info on my v.

by Jeff Daigle, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

It's XM It sounds great

Weaknesses:

Instructions for station setup are weak.

Review:

As far as sound is concerned it's an exceptional piece. Programming stations is relatively easy after you figure it out for yourself. I thought the directions were very weak. Fast & easy hookup. I'm sure as time goes on the display will become more advanced. It's fairly basic. XM at home in high style...buy one!

by Stephen Rose, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

-Performance, build quality -Connection options/flexibility

Weaknesses:

-None

Review:

The Polk XRt12 XM tuner takes XM satellite radio to a whole new level. After using numerous XM radios from Sony and Delphi, the XRt was a breath of fresh air. Audiophile features abound on this tuner; digital out, rca out, solid build construction, and the ability to project the display on your television are highlights. The adjustable blue display is also very cool; styling of the unit in general is sleek/modern. The bass is well controlled and deep reaching. Midrange is glorious, and treble is clear and fairly extended. Earlier XM tuners had rolled-off high frequencies, but the Polk XRt has improved high-end extension. Gone also is the issue with low input; the XRt has a much higher line-level input that matches your average components. Fidelity of the unit seems to fall between fine FM and compact disc playback, realizing that the tuner is limited to what XM transmits. Background noise is far better than FM, but not quite as good as CD. The Polk XRt12 is the only way to listen to XM satellite radio in my opinion....enjoy!

by Dave Conway, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of use, and its look!

Weaknesses:

Like to see a better antenna

Review:

It is just a fine piece of audio equipment! Easy to use and very good sound charateristics.

by walt levy, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

QUALITY OF RICHNESS LOOKS GOOD TOO

Weaknesses:

FOR THE PRICE THEIR ARE NOT ANY

Review:

CAN FIND NO FAULTS AT ALL IN THIS UNIT. GLAD I PURCHASED IT. price very fair

by ken dawkins, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

So far there is not much to compare this unit to other than the portable Delphi and similar units, unless you start talking high-end AM/FM Tuners. I received the Polk unit as a gift and overall am very happy with it. Sonically it is a major improvement over the Delphi unit and I am proud to include it in my Thiel/Classe/Musical Fidelity system. Only two complaints: the compression and fidelity from station to station is inconsistant, but that is likely the fault of XM, not Polk. The other issue for me would be if you choose to want to use the unit without remote, because you are close to it, have too many remotes or whatever, it is tedious to switch stations and you cannot simply punch in a number as you can on the remote. I also wish the viewing window was larger than the Delphi, or at least in the Delphi orange color versus the challenging blue. I am enjoying the Polk piece immensely however, and given the price, believe it to be a value. I look forward to baseball season to catch all my favorite teams on XM at home. Ken Dawkins Director of Sales-Thiel Audio

by Matt KOUDIJS, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

NO FADING STATIONS,

Weaknesses:

DISPLAY A LITTLE TO SMALL TO READ AT 13 FEET AWAY

Review:

VERY NICE,EASY TO USE,LIKE THE REMOTE

by Blake, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound quality. Option to hook up via analog or digital outputs. Everything needed included in the box.

Weaknesses:

The display. I find that the bright blue on black background is nearly impossible to read, unless I am a couple of feet from the tuner.

Review:

The Polk replaced a plug and play unit I had been using for a couple of years. I am using the analog output of the Polk to connect to my tuner. The first thing I noticed was how much more three-dimensional the sound stage was. I even did a side-by-side comparison with the previous tuner. The Polk had noticeably better sound quality. I like the remote better, as it's a good size. I never much liked "credit card" sized remotes, as they can get lost to easily.

by Pete J, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

you can see all the information on the tv screen

Weaknesses:

not all the channels come in crystal clear

Review:

quality product...............its flat out awesome!!!!!

by bankdude, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Toslink/Digital/Optical connections. State-of-the-art, High End, Polk electronics

Weaknesses:

Black and White video feed showing Artist and Song Title. In 2005, it "should" have been in color...at the very least White letters on a Blue background.

Review:

The XRt12 XM digital receiver was a hit the moment it left its box! Until your hear XM through true optical connections or with the analog RCA jacks, using Polk's state-of-the art electronics, you have not yet experienced the fidelity of XM Satellite Radio!! It was the hit of the holiday season at my house! Of course, the video feed to the television is also kewl feature, showing artist and song title. If you can, buy one you will NOT be dissapointed! Joe

by Paul Radzilowski, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Excellent sound quality. Integrates well with a home sound system.

Weaknesses:

I wish the display had more contrast however, since this information can be ported to a TV monitor this is a minor shortcoming.

Review:

I purchased the Polk tuner a few weeks ago after borrowing a friend's Delphi XM car unit. I liked the XM programming but wanted a tuner to work with my home system comprised of a McIntosh preamp and amplifier with electrostatic speakers. The sound quality of the Delphi unit was good but the Polk tuner has a feeling of space and depth in the music not present in the car unit. This is a great product!

by Jimmy Boy Dial, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

What good does it do to have a remote when you have to get so close to an XM receiver to read those tiny screens that you could just as easily use your hand. That's assuming that you don't have all your presets memorized. Well, I'm a dedicated surfer. Now there's no problem at all using the very functional and man sized remote because now (I) can read the channel and song information on a 62inch DLP. And did I say Optical Audio??? Yeah..

Weaknesses:

No memory button on the remote would be the most obvious "weakness". I rarely use that feature but when I do I'd like it to be handy so I don't have to leap my large oak coffee table in a single bound. Additionally, as long as we have the graphics then let's get a bit funky and entertaining. Artist album covers may not be an option but Polk could probably easily outdo Windows Media Player for some kewl incorporated graphics while it's using my wide screen display for simple text information on the channel and song.

Review:

Don't let my review fool you just because I left off one star. This unit is ready willing and able to go to 5.1 but until XM makes that happen then that is a part of the capability of this unit that is not being tested. Therefore, I've reserved that extra star for the future.

by Robert Day, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Being able to see what one is listening to. Aesthetically pleasing to look at!

Weaknesses:

No volume control on the remote.

Review:

Since purchasing the Polk XM radio I've been able to enjoy XM radio far more. It's so easy to install and use, it's wonderful! Five Stars!!!

by D. Schrock, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Works great as promised. Very easy to use and set up. Great!

by David Deininger, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Easy of use--similar operatational attributes and design to the XM SkyFi unit. Attractive component that fits perfectly (size, design, and color) with the other components in my audio rack. Audio is superior to the hand-held, docked XM SkyFi unit.

Weaknesses:

The Polk XRt12 does not support infrared, remote control use--I cannot use the remote control of the unit through the infrared control plates of my whole-house system. I was told Polk is working on a translator to allow infrared to work, but have not seen or heard of a solution yet.

Review:

For those desiring an alternative to terristrial radio in the home, the Polk XRt12 provides an outstanding solution, with an easy-to-use, attractive, component. The unit's audio is superior to the XM SkyFi unit (which I had connected to my home system). I have the unit connected to a whole house system, and it has virtually been operating since I bought it in November 2004.

by Marvin Wilsey, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality and ease of operation.

Weaknesses:

Huh? Are you serious?

Review:

The tuner sounds fantastic! I was very pleased when I found the XRt in the XM Radio weekly bulletin. Jumped right on that! Previously, I had been listening to my Sony, via 12 foot audio cables. Obviously, the Polk XRt-12, feeding into my receiver/amp via a digital coax cable is much better (no hum). I am slightly hampered by my speakers, which is a rather "inexpensive" set of JBLs. Sorry. I did have a large set of Polk Audio (just left and right)speakers, but gave them to my son due to my space limitations.

by nick, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

The sound is alot better then car stereo units. video to the television tells you the name of the song, artist,channel,signal strengh

Weaknesses:

you cant see whats playing on other channels. you have to tune into the channel to see whats playing. small display window on unit.

Review:

Great sound. Easy to hook-up and use.

by Jim Hall, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Appearance, numerous output options.

Weaknesses:

none

Review:

Really makes the sound digital....High's are so clear and the bass really rumbles...It looks really at home in my stereo system. The remote is easy to use and I am very pleased. I can recommend without hesitation.

by Jim Kantrowe, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Very compact.

Weaknesses:

None

Review:

A super product, a super sound!

by David, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Great unit...

by Mike Erspamer, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of set-up and use. High quality sound production.

Weaknesses:

None

Review:

My wife and I have been very impressed by the XRt12 tuner. It was very easy to set up and produces a pure crisp sound quality that both of us enjoy very much. We would recommend the XRt12 to anyone contemplating an in-home satellite radio installation.

by Frank Dolan, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

NONE.

Review:

I LISTEN TO THE XRt12 EVERY DAY. OPTICAL CABLE TO A BOSE 6.1 SYSTEM. THE AUDIO QUALITY IS OUTSTANDING, THE XM LISTENING CHOICES COULDN'T BE BETTER. ONCE YOU HEAR XM THRU THE POLK YOU WILL NEVER GO BACK TO FM OR AM TALK RADIO. MY ONLY COMPLAINT IS I WISH THIS UNIT HAD COME TO MARKET SOONER.

by Bob and Beth, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound and looks. Variety of outputs and ability to link to a whole house system.

Weaknesses:

No pause or repeat. Lenght of antenna cord too short and only size extension is 50 feet.

Review:

XM has become our primary audio source. Much easier than finding that certain CD and better than FM. Before getting the XRt12 we used a Roady in the house. This looks much nicer and has better sound plus the Roady stays in the car where it belongs. The choice of two digitial and an analog output gives good flexibilty. The TV output makes finding out who's on easy but the names should scroll to give complete artist/song title when they are long. The lenght of the antenna cord will require the use of an extension if a window isn't nearby and/or the building interferes with reception. What I would like to see added to this unit the ability to pause or go back and replay a song. The remote has a nice feel in the hand and is the easiest way to operate the unit. Our remote died after a few months but a new one was sent with no questions and no charge. Great customer service. It's nice to see a company back it's products in this manner. I bought this unit because of my experience with Polk speakers and feel it delivers the same great quality.

by Scott E., February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of hook up using either optical or coaxial connections. Ease of use. Solid, digital quality sound. Will look great with any high end home audio system.

Weaknesses:

Remote control is way too large and bulky, and has a cheap look to it.

Review:

An awsome unit! Finally somebody realized that a portable unit doesn't belong with anyone's home audio system! The XRt12 looks great, and took only a couple of minutes to hook up using the optical output and the supplied antenna(which can be placed totally out of sight), and set up is a breeze. The audio quality is pure digital, crisp and clean. The Polk XRt12 Refrence Tuner will be the benchmark of all who follow.

by C B Atkinson, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

great reception of XM signal

Weaknesses:

none

Review:

Excellent receiver with plenty of "bells and whistles" --- well worth the purchase price

by Charlie Fineblum, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

A real home audio quality XM Radio Tuner.

Weaknesses:

Sometimes needs to be rebooted because display gets hosed up.

Review:

I'm very pleased with the overall performance, ease of use and handsome design of my Polk XM Radio Tuner. I was looking for something of home audio quality with discreet components and a real power supply, rather than the "all on one chip" stuff you see in department stores.

by Gerald M. Bell, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Can read the screen acrose the room. Styling and sound quality are superb. Very flexible -- nearly any stereo set-up can accomodate the XRt 12.

Weaknesses:

The remote seems to be rather cheaply made and I fear that in time numbers will wear off the frequently used keys.

Review:

The XRt 12 replaced a Sony XM tuner which I had also been using in the car. The XRt 12is far superior -- brighter, clearer, with great mid-range presence and solid bass. It's features are well thought out and the DAC yields a sound quality which is Soooo close to CD quality. I recently purchased a new amp and discovered the XRt 12 was even cleaner than I had imagined.

by Ken Orlowski, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Size, ease of use, looks,

Weaknesses:

None

Review:

I have never bought a piece of electronics that I was more happier with, it is great, sounds great and easy to use.

by Chris Murphy, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Decent sound without all the cradles, adaptors, etc. of car-to-home units. Antennae is absolutely extraordinary at pulling in the XM signal from challenging locations.

Weaknesses:

Display color was rejected by Sony and should have been by Polk.

Review:

The XRt12 succeeded in eliminating the hassles of cradles and the additional wiring of portable home units. It is certainly on par with these units in terms of audio quality. I was hoping for a beter sonic resolution, but here's where the benefit of having both coaxial and optical digital outputs comes into play. I route the digital signal to my Quad CD player and achieve more musical sounding playback... for me. The remote serves little purpose except for turning the unit off across the room. Why? Because, unfortunately, Polk decided to use the blue on blue display which was rejected by us early users of the Sony DRM-XM1 units. It's difficult to view under any conditions unless you're directly in front of the unit, at eye level, and less than five feet away. Sony moved to a blue on white display in their next generation and the results were superior. Could someone please look into a pop-up 5" LCD screen located on top of the unit? I accept the visual strain in the car, but in the home I expect to be able to see much more clearly. Also, the silver bar that acts as the on/off switch is also a bit confusing. If you try to toggle the silver bars next to the display you'll achieve nothing as the controls are now up/down buttons. One style would have been easier. Yes, I do have a lot of little gripes about this model, but kudos for Matthew Polk for having the courage to bring the first real XM home unit to market. I'm sure that our feedback will be heard and acted upon for the next generation. And XM is too great a medium to be ignored.

by Jay S., February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Good looks. Great sound. What more can you ask.

Weaknesses:

None that I know of yet and have had the unit for 3 months with it working for at least 5 hours per day at a minimum.

Review:

Best product out there. Not only is it sleek looking it also has execptional quality (build as well as sound). Lot of bang for the buck. The sound is top rate. If any of you are concerned about that forget about any objections you may have. All buttons and paddle switches are of excellent quality. The display is easy to read too. Don't think about buying this for too long as you will be missing out on the enjoyment of xmradio in true high fidelity as you ponder a decision.

by Eric S. Solheid, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

none

Review:

Outstanding enjoyment, one of my best purchases.

by Jennifer, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Quality sound, easy to use, and great integration with TV. Finally a product that really works.

by John Grayson, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Clean Sound. Great design for the case.

Weaknesses:

Video is not amazing - but adequate

Review:

For once, the sales pitch matched the receiver. My wife has used XM in her store just up the street and I've been jealous of the great material available on XM. However, I'm a snob when it comes to audio equipment and I wanted clean sound too! The XRt12 is connected to my Sony receiver through a fiber switch and it is everything that I would want. I connected the video to the TV but I don't leave that running normally.

by Ron, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Perfect product like other perfect product from Polk !!!!! Perfect sound !!!

by Wesley Taylor, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Great digital coax output and optical outputs

Weaknesses:

I am completely satisfied.

Review:

Really a great XM receiver

by Michael Spurgeon, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

The main strengths include a width that is the same as other audio components AND two digital outputs.

Weaknesses:

The main weakness that I noticed is a display that is too small to show long names of artists and songs. The video display on the TV could be beefed up to be attractive instead of looking like the screen on an old DOS computer.

Review:

Nice looking unit that fits nicely with the other audio and home theater components. Functionality is very good except that there is not enough room in the little display to show full titles for some songs. The digital outputs are the major plus for this unit--I have it connected via Toslink to a McIntosh MX134 pre/pro. Also, the submenus are excellent for adjusting the supplied antenna.

by Mike Harrison, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of connecting to signal. Instructions were simple.

Weaknesses:

Bland picture for song info. Not enough metal, all plastic buttons, would be better with metal.

Review:

Setting the tuner up was a snap, and took about 10 minutes. Instructions were easy to read and follow.

by Chris Pahl, February 17, 2005

Strengths:

Goes well with the decor, nice sound

Weaknesses:

Display is very small, wish it was larger

Review:

I like the tuner!

by Jim Sheridan, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

After listening to XM Radio for over a year, with my purchase of this receiver it's like hearing XM for the first time again! The clarity and crystal clear true stereo reception is nothing short of stunning!

by Debbie Hollingshead, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

I love the unit.

by Bob Sigmon, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Easy Hook up and use. Sound is good, wish it was 5.1 surround.

Weaknesses:

The display menu(s) could be a little spiffier.

Review:

Great piece of equipment. Easy to hook up and use. If only XM had 5.1 surround sound, this would be just about perfect. Perfect for people who dont have an integrated tuner in there audio equipment.

by Steven Byrnes, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Great Product, easy installation. Great sound

by Michael Moore, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

See above

Weaknesses:

None

Review:

I have owned (and still do) the analog Delphi version and there is quite a difference in sound quality needless to say(to A-B them was very interesting).....The XRt12's sound quality surpasses by two stars...Deeper bass, better S/N ratio and separation are assets of this tuner...Using it's digital audio outs is the key.....

by ARTHUR R TAYLOR JR, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

The slim light weight design asthetically blends with most types of existing equipment. The controls are well designed.

Weaknesses:

The display is ok but not quite sufficient. I would purchase an auxilliary display panel if one were available.

Review:

I like the product very much.

by James Johnson, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound.

Weaknesses:

Display is not great. Antenna was difficult to aim.

Review:

Love it! Got rid of my CD player now that I have XM at home.

by Joey Love, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

ease of installation, various audio options including optical, video out to monitor and use set-up features on your TV.

Weaknesses:

would be great if there was a way to move my presents around on screen and place them in a different position. Say move Top Tracks from Preset A1 to B1.

Review:

Extremely easy to set-up. The screen of the unit is not big but... giving you the ability to connect to your TV takes care of that issue. I was quickly up and running and the sound is superb! If you're an XM subscriber looking for a way to get "high quality" XM feeds in your home, business, etc. I highly recommend this unit. I haven't turned it off yet.

by Robin, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

I absolutely love this. I was listening to XM thru a Roady and while that was nice, this is so much better. I highly recommend the Polk Reference Tuner for the best XM experience.

by James Lencioni, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Excellent frequency response with a large and easy to read display.

Weaknesses:

None

Review:

It is wonderful to finally have a XM radio receiver that has an audio preamplifier that will match the audio levels and frequency response of the rest of the components in my system. The audio quality of the Polk receiver is far superior to Delphi receiver that I was previously using. I would recommend this receiver to anyone looking for a high quality home XM receiver.

by Bill Robinson, February 18, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

Great product. Performs as advertised. With the right coax adapters (from Pasternak Enterprises in Irvine, CA), I was able to simplify the installation by using one of the extra and unused coax cables that I had installed for my DirecTV system to connect from the XRt12 to the roof and then connect to the supplied antenna. Works great.

by Harold Bockelman, February 19, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

My first XM receiver was a Sky-FI two years ago. I just recently upgraded to the Polk Reference Tuner. I was a great fan of XM Radio already. The enjoyment has just increased with the Polk tuner. My favorite channel is XM71 - Watercolors - great smooth jazz on my home system!

by Jason, February 19, 2005

Strengths:

Incredible sound clarity and sleek design.

Weaknesses:

No pause and listen like some other devices.

Review:

The sound clarity of this unit is simply amazing. After listening to XM on my home audio system with this unit, I almost dread listening in my care. This is a must by for true XM fans.

by Stuart Houston, February 19, 2005

Strengths:

tuner design, improved fidelity and xm display to tv feature.

Weaknesses:

none

Review:

As a 15+ year customer of Polk Audio and a 2+ year customer of XM radio, I was pleasantly surprised to hear of the marriage of a great audio speaker manufacturer with digital audio's answer to small dish satellite tv. The RXt12 reference tuner provides the audio clarity the digital format deserves. I am a pleased owner of two of these tuners using one at home and one at my office. My overall listening experience at both is significantly enhanced.

by Pavel Reyes, February 20, 2005

Strengths:

Good looks. Awsome sound.

Weaknesses:

Polk should should still make American products,made in USA.

Review:

At a glance the front panel of the Polk XM tuner is very handsome,I have not seen ANY home or car (with home kit) tuner I would consider to stack up with my home audio until this elegant thing came along. Hook up was a breeze, but the antenna is very fussy on aiming. Once sounds started pouring out of this box (via optical output) I was convinced I did not purchase the Polk just for good looks. Smooth,warm,plenty of depth and sound stage were all present where my older car-home kit tuner fell flat on it's face in comparison. Thanks to the people at Polk that are STILL in tune (!)with audiophiles needs.

by Robert Liss, February 20, 2005

Strengths:

Better sound and the digital coax "out" is a substantial benefit...

Weaknesses:

The unit is still a bit flimsy compared to regular audiophile standards; and unless it is weighted down a bit, tends to move when you touch any of the front panel controls. Also, it would be nice to have some expanded menu controls and station storage over and above what is offered on the other smaller units. For this price you deserve a bit more....

Review:

If you are a big XM fan, as I am; and you like to listen through your audio system rather than just in the car, this unit is a great upgrade from the portable units we have been forced to listen to up until this point in time. A MUCH improved analog converter gives you a a bit better everything to listen to...

by Michael Campbell, February 20, 2005

Strengths:

Clear detailed sound. Deep soundstage. The ability to display the menu on my television is a real plus.

Weaknesses:

The display can be difficult to read from across the room, albeit no more than any other component.

Review:

The XRt12 is a welcome addition to my audio system. In head to head comparisons with music channels on satellite TV as well as various CDs and FM radio, the Polk clearly sounds better than all but my CD player. The XRt12 casts a wide and deep soundstage. Instrument positions are easily identifiable. Overall an excellent product at a good price point.

by Rudy, February 20, 2005

Strengths:

simple integration to existing home entertainment center

Weaknesses:

causes one to actualy listen for a change.

Review:

This is a great add for anyone who is tired of bla bla bla yada yada yada radio. It gives you choice. I never turn on my regular am/fm anymore. It was great to integrate this unit with my whole house entertainment center.

by Mark Brueschke, February 21, 2005

Strengths:

Very easy to set-up, activation took maybe 15 minutes to update the unit.

Weaknesses:

Remote IR strength seems a bit weak.

Review:

Easy to setup, good sound quality, looks sharp. Wish the on-screen graphics were a little flashier.

by Albert Donnenberg, February 22, 2005

Strengths:

This unit is well engineered, with a DAC that appears to be well suited to the signal, and isolated components. The controls are intuitive and easy to use.

Weaknesses:

XM broadcasting is what it is: a compressed digital signal. The fidelity is noticelably less than from a CD played thorugh the same system. Aesthetically, the blue panel and blue power light are keyed to the latest fashion in computer and computer accessory design. This look fits less well with traditional high end audio components.

Review:

We have had the XRt12 for about 3 months, and even since the novelty of XM broadcasting has worn off, it remains the most listened to device on our component system.

by Craig Harley, February 22, 2005

Strengths:

Sounds good; nice appearance; optical connection; easy to set up.

Weaknesses:

Incomplete remote; tuner display hard to see; no memory button on remote;

Review:

This tuner has a very nice look to it; it works very well for its intended purpose & sounds very good with just average equipment (like mine). It has 20 pre-sets, a mute button, a jump button which enables you to go back & forth between your last two stations you were listening to & the ability to display relevent information on your tv screen. It does NOT have volume control on the included remote which forces you to use 2 remotes at the same time to achieve all of the normal use functions; it does NOT have a memory button on the remote but does on the tuner itself; It does NOT have the tune select feature that some XM equipment has; the display on the tuner itself is nearly impossible to see beyond approx 8 feet. Overall this is a nice addition to our home theater set-up but with a few adjustments/additional features it COULD have been superb!!

by David Dewan, February 23, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound. Fast station changes. Very logical remote control. Polk is a speaker company that's proving they understand electronics, too.

Weaknesses:

The remote works perfectly from straight on, but it's weak at more than 30 degrees off to the side. Also, a silver front panel as an option would be nice.

Review:

The XRt12 is well designed, solidly built, and sounds great. The sound isn't quite as good as a well-recorded CD or SACD, but it's much better than Internet radio or MP3, and as good as a strong local FM station. Or more like 60 strong FM stations ... all with inspired programming and no ads. If you like satellite radio in your car, you'll like it even more at home where you can play it through a good amp and big speakers. Polk has a hot product here.

by Howard Hansen, February 23, 2005

Strengths:

Easy to install. Offer many ways to connect. Signal meter very helpful. Great sound.

Weaknesses:

Remote is weak at times. Channel setup is not as intuitive as it should be.

Review:

I love this unit. I have it hooked up to a mid range Whole House system and the sound is awesome. This unit sounds way better than the other guys portable units and XM radio delivers the music the way it was meant to be.

by Herb Newton, February 23, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Review:

finally a true tuner for XM radio with quality Polk features.

by Roy Sackman, February 24, 2005

Strengths:

Fits nicely in stack system. I have mine plugged into an unused video jack.

Weaknesses:

It takes a little practice to master the 4-buttoms on the front that control the menu, memory etc.

Review:

I recall the moment when I played my first CD and heard a favorite symphony with all the precision and detail that medium can deliver. It renewed my love of symphonic music and eager to hear more. Years later, the Polk XRT12 XM Reference Tuner has reminded me again just how great, truly great music can sound. Radio has taken a similar step as recored music did from LP's to CD's with XM: beyond FM in sound quality AND without interruptions! My stero system and the Polk Tuner seemed to be made for each other. If you love music, I recommend you add this to your home system and fall in love all over again - musically speaking.

by J.R.M., February 25, 2005

Strengths:

line out level. digital out. ability to see what is playing on other channels. over quality of item.

Weaknesses:

poor graphics on video out.

Review:

This new xm receiver replaced a first generation sony xm receiver which is hooked up to a whole house audio system. The biggest problem with the sony was the weak line out level. Any time I would switch from xm to another component, I had to adjust the volume down at the main av amp and the pre-out amp for the rest of the house speakers. The new Polk xrt12 has great line out level power to eliminate this problem. The quality of the music is much better as well. I am using the digital out for my theater and analog for the rest of the house. I think this is a great product, you will not be disappointed.

by Dave Surplus, February 26, 2005

Strengths:

Great Audio! Looks great and fits in nicely with sound system.

Weaknesses:

The only downfall is the display. Wish it was a little larger.

Review:

Overall an excellent buy! The ease of use, setup, and the audio is outstanding!!!

by Jody Dowgray, February 28, 2005

Strengths:

I like the idea of a permanent installation so I don't have to transport an XM radio back and forth from the car. The display is easy to read so you can tell at a glance the title of the song and the artist. Reception is perfect, and the remote makes it very easy to change channels.

Weaknesses:

Haven't found any yet.

Review:

I love this radio. It's extremely easy to set up, works great. I have no reception problems, and usually have it on all day. I have speakers throughout my house, so can hear XM wherever I go.

by Dennis C. Shaw, February 28, 2005

Strengths:

1. Audiofile quality sound with digital audio connection; 2. Video connection for viewing information on television.

Weaknesses:

Remote is essentially the same as former XM radio receiver (only larger) and could be redesigned to include a volume control for varied A/V receivers.

Review:

In the summer of 2003, I subscribed to XM radio to provide an alternative source of entertainment in my car for a driving vacation. I was greatly impressed with the programming that XM radio offered and regularly listened to the unit at home over my stereo system. Although the sound was adequate for my car, it lacked the rich high fidelity that one expects of a home stereo. When I learned of the WRt12, I quickly purchased the unit. With a digital audio connection the sound is exceptional and has become one of my favorite components in my system. It has quickly become one of the most commonly used options for the daily listening of music and has made listening to FM radio stations obsolete. There is always an appropriate selection of music for any occasion. The ability to see the information on music selections on my television is also a nice feature and allows me to make station selections from the opposite end of my living room. This unit is clearly the best way to get the most out of your XM radio.

by Pat Gallipoli, February 28, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Would like to see a channel up-down button on the remote thus eliminating the two step process to go the next channel.

Review:

Great receiver.

by Chas Warkomski, March 3, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound, reliable through all kinds of weather

Weaknesses:

A little tough trying to program favorite stations

Review:

Only wish XM radio was around many years ago. Polk does a great a job bringing in all those commerical free stations. It's such a pleasure having such a diversity of uninterupted music with so many choices to suit whatever mood the occasion may call for

by Cs Cummings, March 11, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of setup. Signal received in the middle of house on the lower floor.

Weaknesses:

Review:

I was really impressed with the ease of hooking up my Polkaudio Xm radio. I plugged it right into my stereo receiver and put the antenna about 4 ft away and it worked perfectly. The antenna received the signal in the middle of our house, I did not need to put it by a window. I am very pleased with this unit and the sound that is produced by it.

by Joel H. Light, March 22, 2005

Strengths:

Signal strength and quality.

Weaknesses:

display is too small and not very useful.

Review:

Good power and strong, clear signal. Much better than the portable unit it replaced.

by Thomas S, March 25, 2005

Strengths:

The best quality components and sound that I have experienced to date. RCA and digital simultaneous outs a big plus. Excellent form factor.

Weaknesses:

Though the display is small, the on-TV display makes up for this. However, the lettering is low quality, even on my 60" HDTV, but still very readable.

Review:

This could easily be the greatest XM product to date. I really like the bigger remote, as the small one of the SkiFi did not work past about 10 feet. Absolutely no distortion, where my SkiFi with boombox tended to have a high-pitched hum. Using optical out, and a Harman Kardon AVR-230 receiver, and of course Polk Audio Speakers, it gives the truest sound I have ever heard. I was hard pressed to hear the difference between this and CD. I especially love the fact that it also includes standard RCA outputs for analog audio. Don't be fooled by this analog term, since the analog quality puts the SkiFi to shame, although I never thought much about the SkiFi until I bought this new unit. I use the RCA outs, with an EDIROL USB audio device to capture audio to my laptop using Windows Media Encoder 9 (free). It uses WMA files that I can listen to later, or even edit out specific songs. 8 hours of solid recording takes only 230 MB at CD quality, and only takes 4% CPU power to encode in realtime. I am by no means an expert, but am more than average in my audio experience. So be prepared when XM unleashes 5.1 in their broadcasting repertoire. Coupled with my Monitor 50's, CS1 center, and Monitor 30's surround, and a Velodyne Sub, powered by a HK AVR 230 receiver, I am greatly impressed.

by Bob, April 24, 2005

Strengths:

Definitely for audiophiles willing to setup a high end 5.1 system. This changes the whole equation of home audio (limited to CD players until now).

Weaknesses:

Antenna is a bit weak on overcast days.

Review:

I found the sound & music quality to be so fantastic that I have built an entire 7.1 system around the Polk XRT12. This includes a Monitor70, CS1, PSW10 Sub, etc. I even got Monstor XP cable & gold banana plugs, bi-wiring. The only problem is that on overcast days the reception is hissy. Maybe Polk can improve on the antenna (provide a mini-dish perhaps?). In any case this is one fantastic piece of high-end audio.

by Jim D., May 6, 2005

Strengths:

Digital sound, strong signal, convenient remote

Weaknesses:

Only displays first 16 characters of artist and song title.

Review:

I recently switched from Sirius. The digital sound from the Polk unit is a big improvement. The antenna provides much better signal strength. The blue display is not readable. However I use the TV as the display which works fine. The remote makes it easy to move between channels. Channel delete gets rid of all the stations I don't want to hear. I have one major gripe. Only the first 16 digits of the artist and song title are displayed. XMU, Unsigned, Hear Music and XM Cafe play a lot of artists and songs I haven't heard of before. I end up having to open up the XM online player to get the rest of the name. Otherwise the XRt12 is a major step in the right direction.

by Glackowitz, June 1, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

Needs seperate Preset/direct buttons, direct should be its own ir code

Review:

Is an excellent unit, great sound and has digital and analog out. The onscreen display is a great feature

by Andrew Bajor, June 24, 2005

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

see above.b

Review:

Poor Bass extension. Very limited volume range--volume range as poor as AM radio.

by Polk_User, August 11, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality, reception, ease of setup, asthetically pleasing to look at over all (see weaknesses)

Weaknesses:

Display on unit is way too hard to read unless you are right in front of it. The remote feels 'Cheesy', and the controls are not very intuitive (I still havn't figured out how to use the numbers to select a channel).

Review:

Reception and sound quality are far superior to any other home audio satellite radio receiver I've seen to date. The unit looks and sounds great. I would like to have seen polk make better use of the video out function. The fonts are badly aliased and the song title, even on the video display is limited to 16 characters, which is rarely enough.

by mike, August 27, 2005

Strengths:

Great sound, optical output works great (and they INCLUDE the optical cable), and the video out is a huge bonus.

Weaknesses:

Line level adjustment doesn't seem to do anything.

Review:

This is a great unit and does exactly what it's supposed to do. I had a Delphi home unit and the Polk blows that away for sound quality. I use the optical output to conect to a local amp and the analog connection to connect to my home system. BTW, ignore all the complaints about the 16 character display limit -- that's an XM limitation, not the Polk receiver. And it's 16 characters for the title and 16 for the artist.

Polk Response:

We are glad to hear you're enjoying your tuner. Thought you'd like to know that the Line Level adjustment is only active when using the analog outputs. Output is fixed when using either digital output.

by Robbey, September 17, 2005

Strengths:

Finally, near cd quality sound from XM..'cause we all know "Digital Quality" means NOTHING!!! Except maybe, no static...

Weaknesses:

None for the tuner..hate that XM isn't letting us have cd quality with portables though...

Review:

In 2001, I couldn't wait for XM to become available, and started out with a sony unit as soon as it went on sale. From day one, though, I was disappointed with the sound quality and chalked it up to high compression thinking there was a technological limitation. After listening to this, I realize XM is cheating us. Why aren't the portables capable of crisp, clear sound??? Maybe someone at Polk will answer?? Please?? Just curious, one shouldn't have to pay (269 at fry's)to experience great sound that obviously XM is capable of transmitting...

by David, September 18, 2005

Strengths:

Incredible sound, simple remote, strong signal.

Weaknesses:

My only recommendation would be to make this unit with red LED lights (perhaps as an option) since many high-end component separates have red LED lights.

Review:

I'm the owner of an extremely high end audio system and CD player and I'm truly impressed with the incredible sound quality of this XM tuner. It's my first XM purchase, so, I can't really compare to anything else, but, the deep bass and incredible sound quality is certainly an indicator that this is one excellent XM tuner.

by Ethan, September 29, 2005

Strengths:

keep your delphi

Weaknesses:

none for the unit, just a weak source of musical information. Reverb and presence and brightness are non-existent. Think of a bad MP3, and no matter what receiver you play it through and regardless of digital or analog processing it won't sound any better.

Review:

I honestly think some of these reviews were fabricated. This 'satellite radio' was no better sounding than a Delphi. Based on the reviews I thought this was going to be 'the one'...NOT! The source is to blame. XM crams all 200 stations into limited bandwidth, the result...music that sounds like an MP3 sampled at 64 kbps, end of story! Can't blame Polk, but garbage in garbage out, optical or not, there's no audible difference b/w RCA and optical out on this unit cause the source (XM's squashed frequencies) is crap. Don't buy into the reviews. The best optical music I know thats truly night and day difference b/w RCA and optical has been DirectTV/Hughes box/optical out...now there's incredible sound! I'm extremely dissappointed and frankly, pissed of after buying into these reviews, thinking that possibly there was some sound information that was being lost to RCA outputs,but optical doesn't make squat difference. Believe me!

by LetsGetSirius, September 30, 2005

Strengths:

Sleek Look. Video output a plus (but a little poor).

Weaknesses:

Remote IR codes have toggle bits making programming into control systems a pain. Display too dim - hard to see.

Review:

Probably one of the nicer XM receivers I've seen. Very sleek look (although the display is hard to read). Sound quality is above average for XM, and the unit is pretty easy to use. For control systems trying to control via IR - be aware this unit uses a toggle bit making programming a little more challenging. However, there is an RS232 port if you have the capability to go that route.

Polk Response:

This issue only relates to using the tuner in a distributed audio system with programmable remotes and keypads. If your tuner is in a simple audio system, this issue does not affect you at all. If your unit has a serial number above 40000, your unit will not have these issues at all. For those customers and custom installers with any RS232 or IR control problems, there is a software download that corrects these sorts of issues. Anyone wanting information about control code software or other functionality issues in distributed audio systems should contact Polk customer service at (800)377-7655 or email polkcs@polkaudio.com.

by KPK, October 31, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality seems to make the most of XM signal. The antenna is much better than I expected even considering I have it inside and not directly by a window.

Weaknesses:

Display is tough to see/read in certain situations.

Review:

Overall I'm realling liking it. It sounds great except for channels that seem to have more restricted bandwidth. It's still not CD quality, but it definately does a great job with the material (XM isn't CD quality regardless what anyone says). Still, the sound comes out sounding much better than I expected. The only problem I've had is that the digital outputs don't seem to do anything. I tried both coax and optical without any luck. I know it's not my receiver since I tried it in digital inputs that I had a DVD player and Xbox plugged in to. Both of those components work fine, but plugging in the Polk results in no sound. So far can't find any options I'm missing on the device so maybe it's a manufacturing defect. I'll need to either call for support or check with where I bought it when I get a chance. With that said, I'm not sure that digital output would sound any better since the internal components on this xm tuner might be better than my receiver that it's plugged in to so good analog cables are probably my better option.

Polk Response:

Contact Polk Customer service at 800-377-7655 or email polkcs@polkaudio.com to diagnose the digital output issue.

by XM Fan, November 5, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality, multiple hookup options, large enough remote to feel comfortable in hand but still small enough to not be cumbersome.

Weaknesses:

Annoying blue backlight on power button (when turned off) can't be disabled, up/down buttons work opposite.

Review:

For a home system this is definately the unit to have. After using several receivers designed for a car this one just works better- everything from its design to the multiple outputs make connecting the system easy, regardless of what system it is feeding. Unfortunately, this is clearly Polk's first try at a consumer product, and several annoyances quickly become apparent. Most annoying is the scroll buttons on the unit funtion backwards (pushing "up" scrolls down), also frustrating is the backlit power button.

by pf, December 17, 2005

Strengths:

Sound quality, ease of set-up, appearance

Weaknesses:

Display options could be improved (more options, different background colors)

Review:

Overall this tuner has really exceeded my expectations. The sound quality is superb for the most part. I am a huge fan of jazz and classical music, and the stations offered sound really good using the digital output. Two thumbs up for Polk Audio.

by Mitch Nadler, December 28, 2005

Strengths:

Ease of installation, ease of use, good remote, many audio output options, video display on your TV.

Weaknesses:

Screen could be a bit larger considering the size of the unit, but not really a big deal.

Review:

I have had the Polk XRt12 tuner since it came out last year. I feel sorry for those who cannot hear the difference between this and the Roady 2 or other portable XM receivers. When connected via digital cable to my Onkyo TX-NR901 and Polk RM6900 series speakers the sound quality is crystal clear. You can hear the high end of the piano, symbols, high hats, voices, guitars and the bass lines so clearly. You know it's sharp when you can hear a guitarist sliding his/her fingers across the strings on the neck of the guitar. It is so simple to install too, with plenty of options for audio out. I like the video output to the TV as well as the many options of the screen on the unit (scrolling, still, etc.) Issues I may have with the cut off names and songs is NOT the tuner's problem, but indeed XM radio's limitation (for space considerations, I would imagine). I love listening to XM (Deep Tracks is my favorite - Progressive Rock - just like the late 60's) on this unit. My wife listens to her music, and my 15 year old daughter listens to her "20 on 20" - when we are not home thank goodness. :-) We all have noticed and mentioned to each other the signifant difference between this and FM and between this and the Roady 2 I used to use in the home. As a side note: My daughter loves the "soft-touch" to turn the unit on and off. She used to run to push the On/Off button just because she loves to just "tap" it ever so lightly. OK, not a real good reason to purchase this unit. :-) Finally, I am hoping this unit will be compatible with the new 5.1 surround sound that XM just announced they are going to have on a few stations 24/7 in March of 2006. If so, like WOW!!! :-)

by Alex P, December 29, 2005

Strengths:

Hands down great sound, XM is already good, this product just makes all that much better!

Weaknesses:

Minor annoyances with controls and buttons, really nothing negative (unless 5.1 surround is important to you!)

Review:

Simple to use, Simple to install, much better quality using digital Coax/Optical than standard XM units over analog RCA. Although the unit does support digital Coax/Optical it is NOT compatible with the new XM HD Surround channels schdueled to debut in March 2006 (confirmed today via Tech Support and Product Engineering). So if you are expecting to be ready for 5.1 with the purchase of this product you will not be.

by Rich S., January 7, 2006

Strengths:

Love the presets. Love the compatiblity with my sound system.

Weaknesses:

Difficult to view the display, but that's nit-picking.

Review:

This review is for the XRT12 not the XM service itself. Unfortunately, a few mental midgets here felt compelled to analyze the XM service and/or the quality of programming in their reviews. This section is to review the XRT12!! The tuner is great, and the sound quality is wonderful. Of course, a lot will have to do with your signal strength (see comment about mental midgets above).

by Bob, January 21, 2006

Strengths:

Ease of use. Awesome sound quality

Weaknesses:

Remote control could use a little reworking.

Review:

I bought a Delphi SkyFi shortly after they came out and was very happy with it until a few weeks ago when DirecTV switched from Music Choice to XM channels. The sound from my Delphi immediately seemed flat and didn't seem to travel through my surround system like the sound from my DirecTV did. Problem is, DirecTV doesn't offer all XM channels. So, for quite a few weeks, I fretted and worried and tried to decide if I wanted to bite the bullet and replace my Delphi with the Polk unit. I made the decision last week and was VERY sorry that I hadn't purchased the Polk weeks ago. I had the unit up and running in less than 10 minutes. Maybe even less than 5 minutes. The sound is AWESOME. Surpasses the sound coming out of my DirecTV on the same channels. Some have complained about the small display screen on the unit, but I found the OSD to my tv is very adequate. The only problem I have is with the remote. While it is bigger than the remote for the SkyFi, it isn't quite as well thought out. I miss the up and down buttons that are on my SkyFi remote. BUTTTTT........quite by accident, I learned that the Polk accepts signals from my SkyFi remote rather well, EVEN THE UP AND DOWN CHANNEL BUTTONS. So, for those who really value this feature and are upgrading. They may want to keep the Delphi remote. Or even go out and buy one, since, I think they do sell remotes separately. I am very pleased with this unit. I recommend it highly for use through a home stereo or home surround system.

by Pete, January 28, 2006

Strengths:

Great Audio. Integrates well with other components. Video Output capability.

Weaknesses:

Video output Scrolling is annoying.

Review:

A great sounding product that is simple to setup and use. Specifically strong is the ability to send the XM Display info through the Video Output. I purchased a small display unit specifically to dedicate to this function. Unfortunately, Polk chose to scroll this display and therefore the "full" information is not always on display. At minimum, this would have been nice to be able to have the ability to override the scrolling feature.

by Charlie, April 17, 2006

Strengths:

Audio quality excellent if properly hooked up to quality amp or receiver and speakers. Polk after market service is the best.

Weaknesses:

Inability to support XM HD Surround/Dolby 5.1. One of the reasons I purchased the Polk.

Review:

Since I have no business connection with either Polk or XM, this review is NOT fabricated as suggested by some reviews. Having said that, it is my opinion that the strengths of this receiver far outweigh the inconveniences of the weaknesses outlined in the reviews here concerning issues with the remote and displays. I believe Polk designed a scrolling outboard video display to serve as a screensaver exactly for the same reason why computers support a screensaver. Dishnetwork does the same with their music channels including Sirius. My Polk XM is hooked up using an optical audio output through a Sony home theater receiver supporting Dolby Digital 5.1/DTS. Using a Polk and Velodyne subwoofer, Polk and B & W satellite speakers, and a Boston center channel (quite a hybrid collection, hey?), I never get tired of the outstanding sonics of this setup! Bass, midrange, and treble is real, very well balanced, and exudes a well integrated audio experience! The Sony receiver offers several matrixed surround options in addition to the digital Dolby/DTS. Since XM went HD on Fine Tuning (my favorite channel) and XM Pops, I have noticed more surround effects on these two channels albeit not even close to what a XM HD ready receiver would do. Now here's a cardinal sin and a side note: I sometimes use the FM modulator of a Delphi Roady to play XM through a Magnum DynaLab 101A analog FM tuner. That rivals the Polk for sonics! I had to add that personal eccentricity of mine. Finally, for service Polk is impressive. A few months after getting my first Polk, a freak power surge fried it. I called Polk, and within less than a week Polk replaced it free of charge and no questions asked. This unit has been working great. Overall, I love what I am hearing from music to news/talk channels. I would give the Polk the higest rating, but I chose to subtract a point solely for the fact that the reference tuner won't support XM HD.

by clay, September 1, 2006

Strengths:

digital outputs, large brite display, looks great in a rack with other components (unlike other satalite tuners)

Weaknesses:

audio output still isn't as good as cd's

Review:

i've now been using the XRt12 for 2 years with a harmon/kardon avr535 7.1 reciever (hooked up using optical cable of course), polk front towers, center, sides, rears, and sub. sounds wonderful! not quite as good as the cd's, but the amount of music and other programs at the touch of the remote makes up for that. it looks seamless in the rack with the other components aswell. nice job. now if only XM could get the signal stronger the sound quality would really be as good as cd's.

by Ron H., December 28, 2006

Strengths:

Good reception. Easy to navigate. Delivers what it promises.

Weaknesses:

No unexpected weaknesses. Next generation should be even better.

Review:

Overall very satisfied with the content of XM radio and delivery to my home audio system by the Polk tuner. I've been involved in high-end retail audio for many years. I know that satellite format is not as good sounding as CD or vinyl but variety makes up for everything, and sound quality is very acceptable. If you truly like music and need an alternate source then XM is worth it. The Polk receiver kicks the quality up a notch and is a great addition to a home audio system.

by Peter Page, January 28, 2007

Strengths:

Good quality manufacturing and sound.

Weaknesses:

I see no inherent weakinesses other than the product does not come in silver.

Review:

I borrowered my neighbors Polk receiver and found it to be very musical and of good quality. However, I have a very high end stereo in silver and will not purchase one until it comes in silver. (Important to me)

by OandA Devil, January 9, 2008

Strengths:

Optical input on screen info is good..

Weaknesses:

the scroll is annoying but I can live with that/

Review:

Sounds great now I can hear lil Jimmy insult and yell at people in high quality sound...

by Howard Passman, February 8, 2008

Strengths:

Fair Price. Nice build quality.

Weaknesses:

Small Display Zero feature set. No balanced output. No headphone output or volume control No step up model available No ability to network the output No ability to install a hard drive or at least Compact Flash slot.

Review:

Nice enough looking unit and build quality is nice. It could benifit from a larger display. What's the point of a remote if you have to sit right in front of the unit to see what you're doing. The video output is o.k., but why do I want to waste the life of my TV just to see what I'm listening to. The remote is fairly simple, bu the unit could benefit from a volume control and that goes for remote volumn cabability also. As it is you need a programmable remote or you are forced to sit there with two remotes. One for the radio and one for the receiver or pre-amp to control the volume. The preset is o.k., but again I would like more choices than A or B. It would even be nice to be able to label them with your own labels. A network output would be cool so you could send the output to your PC for recording. Lacking that even a Compact Flash card slot would be helpful. Of course the ability to add a hard drive would be very cool. Lastly, since this unit has a the best DAC in it other than another unit I won't mention for $2500, it would be nice if it had a balanced output. All said and done, it's a nice servicable unit, but it lacks any type of feature set. This in itself wouldn't be that bad, but it doesn't appear as if there is even an upgrade model available. Being new to XM, I was suprised at how little the receivers have evolved.

by colin b, May 24, 2010

Strengths:

Sound quality.

Weaknesses:

None apparent yet.

Review:

I have subscribed to XM Radio for about four years and used the Delphi portable tuner - at home only. My XM is connected to a high grade audio/visual component system (I also have a two-channel audiophile system in the home (more of this later). I did not have great expectations for the Polk, sonically. I bought it mainly for the aesthetics and I was getting fed up with my Delphi falling off the cabinet. So I was very pleasantly surprised with the sound improvement from the Polk over the Delphi - no other changes were made. I am using the analog-out connection and so I can only put the sound improvement down to the better DAC converter and, probably to a lesser extent, the power supply of the Polk. It would be interesting to connect it to my two-channel system using either of the digital-outs and assess the difference that my Musical Fidelity DAC makes. I doubt that it will be that much better though. I am very pleased with this unit.

by Paul D. McDaniel, September 8, 2010

Strengths:

Weaknesses:

None it doses what it should it sounds great

Review:

I think this is best of xm tuners. I sure like my tuner

Wilson Rothman
Time.com
November 17, 2004

"[Listening to XM radio on the Polk XRt12] was the first riveting music experience I'd had in a while—I didn't dare touch the dial...This is the first time I've felt that satellite radio could strike the same emotional chord as CDs or high-quality MP3s."

"Lots of companies talk about quality however, so I was skeptical up until the moment I plugged it into Yamaha's CinemaStation DVX-S650 home theater for a test. I was so impressed with what I heard, I settled down for a long winter's listen."

"Like Polk says, even if you buy the XRt12 receiver, you should hang onto your CD player. Of course, you may never use it again."

[ Open Review ]

Ryan Morris
XMFan.com
November, 2004

"The sound quality on this tuner is amazing! When listening to the tuner using the digital output you will hear amazing clarity that you won't get from hooking up your SkyFi or Roady in your home. If you don't have a newer home A/V receiver with digital inputs, don't worry because the analog output of this tuner sounds very, very good (the XRt12 uses Burr-Brown Digital-to-Analog Converter)."

"Bottom line: I'm impressed. I was getting frustrated with XM's lack of a home receiver, but now I'm speechless. Whether this is a radio for yourself, or a gift, it's $299 well-spent."

[ Open Review ]

Wes Phillips
Stereophile.com
December 2004

"It [The Polk XRt12 tuner] has a feature that must have been designed with relentless music seekers like me in mind: the Memory button. If I hear something I like, all I have to do is press the XRt12's front-panel Memory button and it will retain the text scroll identifying the artist and song (10 songs total); later, I can access the Memory Recall function and get out my notepad."

"I'd dabbled with XM a while back, auditioning Sony's original car/home satellite receiver, a product whose mediocre sound quality was surpassed only by its phenomenally clunky user interface. But the Polk XRt12 was bruited as a horse of a different color.

For one thing, it wasn't a product scaled down to be slipped into a docking cradle in a dashboard or boombox—it was designed around a component-sized (17" wide) chassis and packed with a Burr-Brown DAC, a special power supply, a high-quality adjustable gain card, and a circuit topology that places the power supply, display, outputs, preamp, and tuner on discrete circuit boards in the quest for lower noise/minimized interference.

It also has something I've never seen on a satellite radio tuner: digital outs. The analog outputs sound surprisingly robust, with solid bass and timbre that were extremely natural compared to what I'd heard emanating from the Sony. Attach the XRt12 to a fancy-schmancy outboard DAC, however, such as the Musical Fidelity X-DACV3 I had on hand, and it gets even better.

"If I say that my initial experience with XM is that the sound is better than the average FM station, that's faint praise. But I think it's better than that—at least through the Polk XRt12."

[ Open Review ]

Mike Ryan
BostonHerald.com
December 2004

"Polk Audio has developed a beautiful new product that incorporates satellite radio technology and excellent fidelity. The Polk Audio XRt12 Tuner would make an ideal holiday gift for the music lover on your list...It is crafted with a stylish, sleek and modern look and delivers superb fidelity."

[ Open Review ]

M. Carroll, Phoenix, AZ
XRt12 owner

"I had to write and tell you how superb your XM radio Audiophile player is. I had my XM radio plugged in through the home cradle with the analog output...it was good, but nothing compared me for how superb your unit is. I have good equipment, good cables and your unit produces CD quality music for thousands less than my CD player. Thank you for a wonderful product!"

Sound & Vision
Feb/Mar 2005

"The XRt12 sounded better...noticeably better. Bass was deeper and tighter, the midrange seemed fuller, with more presence, and the treble was more sparkling."

"The component size, cool styling and abundant connectors of Polk Audio's tuner make it a welcome addition to any equipment stack...put the XRt12 tuner on your short list."

Louis Ramirez
Time Out New York Issue 480: December 9–15, 2004

"Polk's home-theater units have a stellar reputation, so we weren't surprised by the XRt12's crystal-clear sound. Whether we were listening to Interpol or Ella Fitzgerald, the system delivered muscular bass and razor-sharp vocals."

[ Open Review ]

David Dritsas
E-Gear magazine
January/February 2005

""[The XRt12 does] real justice to the high-quality audio XM delivers for its music channels...I really like this tuner."

CNET.com, February 2005

—Steve Guttenberg

"The bottom line: Polk's homebound XM radio sets a new standard for satellite radio sound quality."

"...refined listeners now have an alternative: Polk's XRt12 XM Reference Tuner is the first satellite radio that's truly audiophile-grade...the XRt12's sound was truly remarkable, with vivid transparency and a deep soundstage...the XRt12 is the best-sounding satellite radio we've tested."

[ Open Review ]

Bill Lammers
Cleveland Plain Dealer, February 3, 2005

"...the sound [of the Polk XRt12] is more spacious, with better imaging of powerful bass and stinging treble - far less compressed than what I have found with plug-and-play units hooked into the same stereo system."
"With the Polk XRt12, you can live that musical life from the luxury of your favorite comfy chair with the full fidelity of a true home audio component. Can there be any better excuse?"

[ Open Review ]

Jeff Van Dyne
GoodSound.com
February, 2005

"I'm convinced that, sometime during the last 30 years, robots took over FM radio. You have to admit that they're consistent -- consistently bad."

"...FM has been taken over by corporate America, with the result that the independents are all but dead, and along with them most of the innovative and cutting-edge programming. By the time you hear anything coming out of your radio today, it's been programmed, processed, and homogenized to make sure it's just like everything else. This is no way to run a radio station. Judging by the droves of people abandoning FM as a music source, it seems a lot of you agree."

"If you love music, you want satellite radio. Period. As far as I'm concerned, this is the coolest thing since sliced bread. No, it's way cooler than that. Really."

"Suffice it to say that the Polk XRt12 offers a number of advantages that fully justify its price and status as a dedicated tuner in your home system."

"the XRt12's construction and electronics will squeeze every last drop of performance out of the medium that it is currently possible to squeeze. Overall, I found the sound quality excellent. While still a notch below that of CD, it was clearly superior to MP3 and FM broadcasts."

"The Polk XRt12 XM tuner is a no-brainer. A lot of equipment cycles through our house over the course of a year, but this unit has completed a one-way trip...Its sound quality is good enough to satisfy my audiophile tendencies, and the continuous voyage of musical discovery is enough to keep both of us settled into our listening chairs for hours on end. I don't care where you live or what your musical tastes are -- the XRt12 should be on your short list to audition."

[ Open Review ]

Gary Krakow
MSNBC.com

"As for sound -- the Polk is the best sounding component tuner that I've ever heard in my system...the Polk seems to go higher in the treble and lower in the bass -- as well as providing much better stereo separation between the speakers."

[ Open Review ]

Chris Boylan
BigPictureBigSound.com
May 2005

"I really enjoyed my time with the Polk XM tuner. It introduced me to XM Radio and for that I am grateful. 'Fred' has helped me to reconnect to my favorite music from the 80s and 90s and other XM stations have introduced me to new pleasures as well, in many different genres."

[ Open Review ]

Piero Gabucci
Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity
June, 2005

"The remote is simply laid out and easily understandable. It reminds me of the early days of remotes with on/off, volume and channel change, (refreshing actually considering the new universal trends)."

"In our age of MP3 acceptable sound quality, the Polk XM tuner is more than satisfying. I've noticed that it's playing in our house for background music constantly, telling me we are enjoying it. The only problem is the fight for which channel."

"Radio is back! The Polk Audio XM Satellite Digital Radio Tuner definitely is heads and tails above any music service I've experienced. The Polk Audio XRt12 is now a permanent component in my system."

[ Open Review ]